BRETT BUTLER Rookie Card Value & Price Guide (2026)

BRETT BUTLER Baseball Cards

This page lists all known BRETT BUTLER rookie cards — 49 cards in our database spanning 1982–1998, covering sets from DONRUSS, UPPER DECK, FLEER and more. Prices are sourced from recent market sales and reflect current collector values.

#1 Rookie Card

BRETT BUTLER STEVE BEDROSIAN /BRETT BUTLER /LARRY OWEN

$1.50

1982 TOPPS 1982 TOPPS set No. 502

#2

BRETT BUTLER

$0.20

1983 DONRUSS 1983 DONRUSS set No. 636

#3

BRETT BUTLER

$0.40

1984 FLEER 1984 FLEER set No. 173

#4

BRETT BUTLER

$0.40

1985 FLEER 1985 FLEER set No. 441

#5

BRETT BUTLER

$2.00

1985 TOPPS TIFFANY 1985 TOPPS TIFFANY set No. 637

#6

BRETT BUTLER

$0.25

1986 DONRUSS 1986 DONRUSS set No. 12

#7

BRETT BUTLER

$0.25

1986 DONRUSS 1986 DONRUSS set No. 102

#8

BRETT BUTLER

$0.15

1987 DONRUSS 1987 DONRUSS set No. 219

#9

BRETT BUTLER

$0.25

1987 FLEER 1987 FLEER set No. 246

#10

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1988 DONRUSS 1988 DONRUSS set No. 279

#11

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1988 O-PEE-CHEE 1988 O-PEE-CHEE set No. 202

#12

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1989 BOWMAN 1989 BOWMAN set No. 480

#13

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1989 DONRUSS 1989 DONRUSS set No. 217

#14

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1989 FLEER 1989 FLEER set No. 324

#15

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1990 BOWMAN 1990 BOWMAN set No. 237

#16

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1990 DONRUSS 1990 DONRUSS set No. 249

#17

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1990 FLEER 1990 FLEER set No. 53

#18

BRETT BUTLER

$0.20

1990 UPPER DECK 1990 UPPER DECK set No. 119

#19

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1991 DONRUSS 1991 DONRUSS set No. 143

#20

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1991 FLEER 1991 FLEER set No. 257

#21

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1991 O-PEE-CHEE PREMIER 1991 O-PEE-CHEE PREMIER set No. 16

#22

BRETT BUTLER

$0.15

1991 STUDIO 1991 STUDIO set No. 181

#23

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1991 UPPER DECK 1991 UPPER DECK set No. 270

#24

BRETT BUTLER

$0.50

1992 BOWMAN 1992 BOWMAN set No. 597

#25

BRETT BUTLER

$0.15

1992 LEAF 1992 LEAF set No. 186

#26

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1992 O-PEE-CHEE PREMIER 1992 O-PEE-CHEE PREMIER set No. 145

#27

BRETT BUTLER

$0.20

1992 PINNACLE 1992 PINNACLE set No. 133

#28

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1992 PINNACLE 1992 PINNACLE set No. 619

#29

BRETT BUTLER

$0.15

1992 STADIUM CLUB 1992 STADIUM CLUB set No. 292

#30

BRETT BUTLER

$0.15

1992 STUDIO 1992 STUDIO set No. 41

#31

BRETT BUTLER

$0.20

1992 ULTRA 1992 ULTRA set No. 209

#32

BRETT BUTLER

$0.10

1992 UPPER DECK 1992 UPPER DECK set No. 307

#33

BRETT BUTLER

$0.30

1993 BOWMAN 1993 BOWMAN set No. 422

#34

BRETT BUTLER

$0.20

1993 FLEER 1993 FLEER set No. 59

#35

BRETT BUTLER

$0.15

1993 PINNACLE 1993 PINNACLE set No. 487

#36

BRETT BUTLER

$0.20

1993 UPPER DECK 1993 UPPER DECK set No. 259

#37

BRETT BUTLER

$0.40

1994 BOWMAN 1994 BOWMAN set No. 382

#38

BRETT BUTLER

$0.40

1994 BOWMAN 1994 BOWMAN set No. 622

#39

BRETT BUTLER

$0.30

1994 STADIUM CLUB 1994 STADIUM CLUB set No. 121

#40

BRETT BUTLER

$0.30

1994 UPPER DECK 1994 UPPER DECK set No. 183

#41

BRETT BUTLER

$0.50

1995 BOWMAN 1995 BOWMAN set No. 287

#42

BRETT BUTLER BRETT BUTLER CL

$0.15

1995 DONRUSS 1995 DONRUSS set No. 160

#43

BRETT BUTLER

$0.30

1995 DONRUSS 1995 DONRUSS set No. 390

#44

BRETT BUTLER

$0.30

1995 STADIUM CLUB 1995 STADIUM CLUB set No. 242

#45

BRETT BUTLER

$0.15

1995 STADIUM CLUB 1995 STADIUM CLUB set No. 629

#46

BRETT BUTLER

$0.30

1995 UPPER DECK 1995 UPPER DECK set No. 364

#47

BRETT BUTLER

$0.30

1996 DONRUSS 1996 DONRUSS set No. 515

#48

BRETT BUTLER

$0.30

1996 UPPER DECK 1996 UPPER DECK set No. 357

#49

BRETT BUTLER

$0.30

1998 UPPER DECK 1998 UPPER DECK set No. 116

Baseball Player