DON MATTINGLY   Rookie Card

Value & price guide for DON MATTINGLY rookie cards — updated 2026.

DON MATTINGLY Baseball Cards

This page lists all known DON MATTINGLY rookie cards — 52 cards in our database spanning 1984–2019, covering sets from DONRUSS, FLEER, UPPER DECK and more. Prices are sourced from recent market sales and reflect current collector values.

#1 Rookie Card

DON MATTINGLY

$20.00
1984 FLEER 1984 FLEER set No. 131
#2

DON MATTINGLY

$5.00
1985 FLEER 1985 FLEER set No. 133
#3

DON MATTINGLY

$20.00
1985 TOPPS TIFFANY 1985 TOPPS TIFFANY set No. 665
#4

DON MATTINGLY

$2.50
1986 DONRUSS 1986 DONRUSS set No. 173
#5

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
1987 DONRUSS 1987 DONRUSS set No. 52
#6

DON MATTINGLY

$2.00
1987 FLEER 1987 FLEER set No. 104
#7

DON MATTINGLY

$0.60
1987 TOPPS 1987 TOPPS set No. 500
#8

DON MATTINGLY

$0.30
1987 TOPPS 1987 TOPPS set No. 606
#9

DON MATTINGLY

$1.00
1987 TOPPS 1987 TOPPS set No. 606A
#10

DON MATTINGLY

$0.60
1988 DONRUSS 1988 DONRUSS set No. 217
#11

DON MATTINGLY

$0.75
1988 O-PEE-CHEE 1988 O-PEE-CHEE set No. 300
#12

DON MATTINGLY

$0.60
1989 BOWMAN 1989 BOWMAN set No. 176
#13

DON MATTINGLY

$0.30
1989 DONRUSS 1989 DONRUSS set No. 26
#14

DON MATTINGLY

$0.60
1989 FLEER 1989 FLEER set No. 258
#15

DON MATTINGLY

$0.60
1990 BOWMAN 1990 BOWMAN set No. 443
#16

DON MATTINGLY

$0.60
1990 DONRUSS 1990 DONRUSS set No. 190
#17

DON MATTINGLY

$0.60
1990 FLEER 1990 FLEER set No. 447
#18

DON MATTINGLY

$0.20
1990 FLEER 1990 FLEER set No. 626
#19

DON MATTINGLY DON MATTINGLY/ MARK MCGWIRE

$0.30
1990 FLEER 1990 FLEER set No. 638
#20

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
1990 UPPER DECK 1990 UPPER DECK set No. 191
#21

DON MATTINGLY

$0.60
1991 DONRUSS 1991 DONRUSS set No. 107
#22

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
1991 ULTRA 1991 ULTRA set No. 239
#23

DON MATTINGLY

$0.60
1991 UPPER DECK 1991 UPPER DECK set No. 354
#24

DON MATTINGLY

$3.00
1992 BOWMAN 1992 BOWMAN set No. 340
#25

DON MATTINGLY

$1.00
1992 LEAF 1992 LEAF set No. 57
#26

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
1992 PINNACLE 1992 PINNACLE set No. 23
#27

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
1992 STADIUM CLUB 1992 STADIUM CLUB set No. 420
#28

DON MATTINGLY

$1.00
1992 STUDIO 1992 STUDIO set No. 216
#29

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
1992 ULTRA 1992 ULTRA set No. 105
#30

DON MATTINGLY

$0.60
1992 UPPER DECK 1992 UPPER DECK set No. 356
#31

DON MATTINGLY

$2.00
1993 BOWMAN 1993 BOWMAN set No. 595
#32

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
1993 DONRUSS 1993 DONRUSS set No. 609
#33

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
1993 FLEER 1993 FLEER set No. 281
#34

DON MATTINGLY

$2.00
1993 PINNACLE 1993 PINNACLE set No. 23
#35

DON MATTINGLY

$1.00
1993 PINNACLE 1993 PINNACLE set No. 470
#36

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
1993 UPPER DECK 1993 UPPER DECK set No. 134
#37

DON MATTINGLY

$2.50
1994 BOWMAN 1994 BOWMAN set No. 25
#38

DON MATTINGLY

$2.50
1994 BOWMAN 1994 BOWMAN set No. 386
#39

DON MATTINGLY

$2.00
1994 STADIUM CLUB 1994 STADIUM CLUB set No. 195
#40

DON MATTINGLY

$1.00
1994 UPPER DECK 1994 UPPER DECK set No. 290
#41

DON MATTINGLY

$3.00
1995 BOWMAN 1995 BOWMAN set No. 282
#42

DON MATTINGLY

$2.00
1995 DONRUSS 1995 DONRUSS set No. 55
#43

DON MATTINGLY

$1.00
1995 DONRUSS 1995 DONRUSS set No. 220
#44

DON MATTINGLY

$1.00
1995 DONRUSS 1995 DONRUSS set No. 440
#45

DON MATTINGLY

$1.00
1995 STADIUM CLUB 1995 STADIUM CLUB set No. 212
#46

DON MATTINGLY

$2.00
1995 STADIUM CLUB 1995 STADIUM CLUB set No. 381
#47

DON MATTINGLY

$2.00
1995 UPPER DECK 1995 UPPER DECK set No. 210
#48

DON MATTINGLY

$2.00
1996 DONRUSS 1996 DONRUSS set No. 301
#49

DON MATTINGLY

$2.00
1996 UPPER DECK 1996 UPPER DECK set No. 154
#50

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
2014 PANINI PRIZM 2014 PANINI PRIZM set No. 163
#51

DON MATTINGLY

$1.25
2014 TOPPS ARCHIVES 2014 TOPPS ARCHIVES set No. 160
#52

DON MATTINGLY

$1.50
2019 STADIUM CLUB 2019 STADIUM CLUB set No. 157