Skip to content
The Baseball Cards GuideFREE PRICE GUIDE
Baseball Team Tracker – free Wear OS watch face

HomePrice Guide

DON MATTINGLY rookie cards

Value & price guide for DON MATTINGLY rookie cards — updated 2026.

This page lists all known DON MATTINGLY rookie cards — 52 cards in our database spanning 1984–2019, covering sets from DONRUSS, FLEER, UPPER DECK and more. Prices are sourced from recent market sales and reflect current collector values.

52 cards found for DON MATTINGLY
#CardYearSetValue
1 Rookie CardDON MATTINGLYNo. 131 1984 FLEER $20.00
2 DON MATTINGLYNo. 133 1985 FLEER $5.00
3 DON MATTINGLYNo. 665 1985 TOPPS TIFFANY $20.00
4 DON MATTINGLYNo. 173 1986 DONRUSS $2.50
5 DON MATTINGLYNo. 52 1987 DONRUSS $1.25
6 DON MATTINGLYNo. 104 1987 FLEER $2.00
7 DON MATTINGLYNo. 500 1987 TOPPS $0.60
8 DON MATTINGLYNo. 606 1987 TOPPS $0.30
9 DON MATTINGLYNo. 606A 1987 TOPPS $1.00
10 DON MATTINGLYNo. 217 1988 DONRUSS $0.60
11 DON MATTINGLYNo. 300 1988 O-PEE-CHEE $0.75
12 DON MATTINGLYNo. 176 1989 BOWMAN $0.60
13 DON MATTINGLYNo. 26 1989 DONRUSS $0.30
14 DON MATTINGLYNo. 258 1989 FLEER $0.60
15 DON MATTINGLYNo. 443 1990 BOWMAN $0.60
16 DON MATTINGLYNo. 190 1990 DONRUSS $0.60
17 DON MATTINGLYNo. 447 1990 FLEER $0.60
18 DON MATTINGLYNo. 626 1990 FLEER $0.20
19 DON MATTINGLYDON MATTINGLY/ MARK MCGWIRENo. 638 1990 FLEER $0.30
20 DON MATTINGLYNo. 191 1990 UPPER DECK $1.25
21 DON MATTINGLYNo. 107 1991 DONRUSS $0.60
22 DON MATTINGLYNo. 239 1991 ULTRA $1.25
23 DON MATTINGLYNo. 354 1991 UPPER DECK $0.60
24 DON MATTINGLYNo. 340 1992 BOWMAN $3.00
25 DON MATTINGLYNo. 57 1992 LEAF $1.00
26 DON MATTINGLYNo. 23 1992 PINNACLE $1.25
27 DON MATTINGLYNo. 420 1992 STADIUM CLUB $1.25
28 DON MATTINGLYNo. 216 1992 STUDIO $1.00
29 DON MATTINGLYNo. 105 1992 ULTRA $1.25
30 DON MATTINGLYNo. 356 1992 UPPER DECK $0.60
31 DON MATTINGLYNo. 595 1993 BOWMAN $2.00
32 DON MATTINGLYNo. 609 1993 DONRUSS $1.25
33 DON MATTINGLYNo. 281 1993 FLEER $1.25
34 DON MATTINGLYNo. 23 1993 PINNACLE $2.00
35 DON MATTINGLYNo. 470 1993 PINNACLE $1.00
36 DON MATTINGLYNo. 134 1993 UPPER DECK $1.25
37 DON MATTINGLYNo. 25 1994 BOWMAN $2.50
38 DON MATTINGLYNo. 386 1994 BOWMAN $2.50
39 DON MATTINGLYNo. 195 1994 STADIUM CLUB $2.00
40 DON MATTINGLYNo. 290 1994 UPPER DECK $1.00
41 DON MATTINGLYNo. 282 1995 BOWMAN $3.00
42 DON MATTINGLYNo. 55 1995 DONRUSS $2.00
43 DON MATTINGLYNo. 220 1995 DONRUSS $1.00
44 DON MATTINGLYNo. 440 1995 DONRUSS $1.00
45 DON MATTINGLYNo. 212 1995 STADIUM CLUB $1.00
46 DON MATTINGLYNo. 381 1995 STADIUM CLUB $2.00
47 DON MATTINGLYNo. 210 1995 UPPER DECK $2.00
48 DON MATTINGLYNo. 301 1996 DONRUSS $2.00
49 DON MATTINGLYNo. 154 1996 UPPER DECK $2.00
50 DON MATTINGLYNo. 163 2014 PANINI PRIZM $1.25
51 DON MATTINGLYNo. 160 2014 TOPPS ARCHIVES $1.25
52 DON MATTINGLYNo. 157 2019 STADIUM CLUB $1.50