GARY SHEFFIELD   Rookie Card

Value & price guide for GARY SHEFFIELD rookie cards — updated 2026.

GARY SHEFFIELD Baseball Cards

This page lists all known GARY SHEFFIELD rookie cards — 66 cards in our database spanning 1989–2009, covering sets from UPPER DECK, BOWMAN, FLEER and more. Prices are sourced from recent market sales and reflect current collector values.

#1 Rookie Card

GARY SHEFFIELD

$1.50
1989 BOWMAN 1989 BOWMAN set No. 142
#2 Rookie Card

GARY SHEFFIELD

$1.50
1989 DONRUSS 1989 DONRUSS set No. 31
#3 Rookie Card

GARY SHEFFIELD

$1.50
1989 FLEER 1989 FLEER set No. 196
#4

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.25
1990 BOWMAN 1990 BOWMAN set No. 391
#5

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.25
1990 DONRUSS 1990 DONRUSS set No. 501
#6

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.25
1990 FLEER 1990 FLEER set No. 336
#7

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.50
1990 UPPER DECK 1990 UPPER DECK set No. 157
#8

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.10
1991 FLEER 1991 FLEER set No. 596
#9

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.20
1991 ULTRA 1991 ULTRA set No. 180
#10

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.10
1991 UPPER DECK 1991 UPPER DECK set No. 266
#11

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.50
1992 BOWMAN 1992 BOWMAN set No. 214
#12

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.15
1992 LEAF 1992 LEAF set No. 446
#13

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.20
1992 PINNACLE 1992 PINNACLE set No. 235
#14

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.15
1992 STADIUM CLUB 1992 STADIUM CLUB set No. 309
#15

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.15
1992 STUDIO 1992 STUDIO set No. 108
#16

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.20
1992 ULTRA 1992 ULTRA set No. 582
#17

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.10
1992 UPPER DECK 1992 UPPER DECK set No. 234
#18

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1993 BOWMAN 1993 BOWMAN set No. 490
#19

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.20
1993 DONRUSS 1993 DONRUSS set No. 444
#20

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.20
1993 FLEER 1993 FLEER set No. 147
#21

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.10
1993 FLEER 1993 FLEER set No. 351
#22

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1993 PINNACLE 1993 PINNACLE set No. 1
#23

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.20
1993 UPPER DECK 1993 UPPER DECK set No. 222
#24

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.10
1993 UPPER DECK 1993 UPPER DECK set No. 492
#25

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.10
1993 UPPER DECK 1993 UPPER DECK set No. 494
#26

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.40
1994 BOWMAN 1994 BOWMAN set No. 290
#27

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1994 STADIUM CLUB 1994 STADIUM CLUB set No. 4
#28

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.15
1994 UPPER DECK 1994 UPPER DECK set No. 50
#29

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.15
1994 UPPER DECK 1994 UPPER DECK set No. 271
#30

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1994 UPPER DECK 1994 UPPER DECK set No. 475
#31

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.50
1995 BOWMAN 1995 BOWMAN set No. 325
#32

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1995 DONRUSS 1995 DONRUSS set No. 168
#33

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.15
1995 STADIUM CLUB 1995 STADIUM CLUB set No. 500
#34

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1995 UPPER DECK 1995 UPPER DECK set No. 355
#35

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1996 DONRUSS 1996 DONRUSS set No. 36
#36

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1996 UPPER DECK 1996 UPPER DECK set No. 340
#37

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1997 BOWMAN 1997 BOWMAN set No. 231
#38

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1997 UPPER DECK 1997 UPPER DECK set No. 360
#39

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1998 ULTRA 1998 ULTRA set No. 43
#40

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1998 ULTRA 1998 ULTRA set No. 253
#41

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1998 UPPER DECK 1998 UPPER DECK set No. 369
#42

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1998 UPPER DECK 1998 UPPER DECK set No. 428
#43

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1999 BOWMAN 1999 BOWMAN set No. 11
#44

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
1999 UPPER DECK 1999 UPPER DECK set No. 124
#45

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2000 BOWMAN 2000 BOWMAN set No. 134
#46

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2000 UPPER DECK 2000 UPPER DECK set No. 409
#47

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2001 BOWMAN 2001 BOWMAN set No. 58
#48

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2001 UPPER DECK 2001 UPPER DECK set No. 194
#49

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2002 BOWMAN 2002 BOWMAN set No. 48
#50

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2002 UPPER DECK 2002 UPPER DECK set No. 329
#51

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2002 UPPER DECK 2002 UPPER DECK set No. 638
#52

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2003 BOWMAN 2003 BOWMAN set No. 3
#53

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2003 UPPER DECK 2003 UPPER DECK set No. 142
#54

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2004 BOWMAN 2004 BOWMAN set No. 24
#55

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2004 UPPER DECK 2004 UPPER DECK set No. 142
#56

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2004 UPPER DECK 2004 UPPER DECK set No. 472
#57

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2005 BOWMAN 2005 BOWMAN set No. 60
#58

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2005 UPPER DECK 2005 UPPER DECK set No. 136
#59

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.40
2006 FLEER 2006 FLEER set No. 391
#60

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.40
2006 UPPER DECK 2006 UPPER DECK set No. 308
#61

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.40
2007 UPPER DECK 2007 UPPER DECK set No. 168
#62

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.30
2008 BOWMAN 2008 BOWMAN set No. 159
#63

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.60
2008 SPx 2008 SPx set No. 34
#64

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.40
2008 UPPER DECK 2008 UPPER DECK set No. 269
#65

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.40
2009 UPPER DECK 2009 UPPER DECK set No. 130
#66

GARY SHEFFIELD

$0.40
2009 UPPER DECK 2009 UPPER DECK set No. 640
Are you Ambitious? Personality Test