Skip to content
The Baseball Cards GuideFREE PRICE GUIDE

HomePrice Guide

GARY SHEFFIELD rookie cards

Value & price guide for GARY SHEFFIELD rookie cards — updated 2026.

This page lists all known GARY SHEFFIELD rookie cards — 66 cards in our database spanning 1989–2009, covering sets from UPPER DECK, BOWMAN, FLEER and more. Prices are sourced from recent market sales and reflect current collector values.

66 cards found for GARY SHEFFIELD
#CardYearSetValue
1 Rookie CardGARY SHEFFIELDNo. 142 1989 BOWMAN $1.50
2 Rookie CardGARY SHEFFIELDNo. 31 1989 DONRUSS $1.50
3 Rookie CardGARY SHEFFIELDNo. 196 1989 FLEER $1.50
4 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 391 1990 BOWMAN $0.25
5 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 501 1990 DONRUSS $0.25
6 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 336 1990 FLEER $0.25
7 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 157 1990 UPPER DECK $0.50
8 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 596 1991 FLEER $0.10
9 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 180 1991 ULTRA $0.20
10 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 266 1991 UPPER DECK $0.10
11 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 214 1992 BOWMAN $0.50
12 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 446 1992 LEAF $0.15
13 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 235 1992 PINNACLE $0.20
14 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 309 1992 STADIUM CLUB $0.15
15 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 108 1992 STUDIO $0.15
16 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 582 1992 ULTRA $0.20
17 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 234 1992 UPPER DECK $0.10
18 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 490 1993 BOWMAN $0.30
19 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 444 1993 DONRUSS $0.20
20 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 147 1993 FLEER $0.20
21 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 351 1993 FLEER $0.10
22 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 1 1993 PINNACLE $0.30
23 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 222 1993 UPPER DECK $0.20
24 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 492 1993 UPPER DECK $0.10
25 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 494 1993 UPPER DECK $0.10
26 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 290 1994 BOWMAN $0.40
27 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 4 1994 STADIUM CLUB $0.30
28 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 50 1994 UPPER DECK $0.15
29 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 271 1994 UPPER DECK $0.15
30 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 475 1994 UPPER DECK $0.30
31 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 325 1995 BOWMAN $0.50
32 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 168 1995 DONRUSS $0.30
33 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 500 1995 STADIUM CLUB $0.15
34 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 355 1995 UPPER DECK $0.30
35 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 36 1996 DONRUSS $0.30
36 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 340 1996 UPPER DECK $0.30
37 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 231 1997 BOWMAN $0.30
38 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 360 1997 UPPER DECK $0.30
39 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 43 1998 ULTRA $0.30
40 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 253 1998 ULTRA $0.30
41 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 369 1998 UPPER DECK $0.30
42 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 428 1998 UPPER DECK $0.30
43 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 11 1999 BOWMAN $0.30
44 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 124 1999 UPPER DECK $0.30
45 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 134 2000 BOWMAN $0.30
46 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 409 2000 UPPER DECK $0.30
47 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 58 2001 BOWMAN $0.30
48 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 194 2001 UPPER DECK $0.30
49 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 48 2002 BOWMAN $0.30
50 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 329 2002 UPPER DECK $0.30
51 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 638 2002 UPPER DECK $0.30
52 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 3 2003 BOWMAN $0.30
53 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 142 2003 UPPER DECK $0.30
54 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 24 2004 BOWMAN $0.30
55 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 142 2004 UPPER DECK $0.30
56 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 472 2004 UPPER DECK $0.30
57 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 60 2005 BOWMAN $0.30
58 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 136 2005 UPPER DECK $0.30
59 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 391 2006 FLEER $0.40
60 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 308 2006 UPPER DECK $0.40
61 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 168 2007 UPPER DECK $0.40
62 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 159 2008 BOWMAN $0.30
63 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 34 2008 SPx $0.60
64 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 269 2008 UPPER DECK $0.40
65 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 130 2009 UPPER DECK $0.40
66 GARY SHEFFIELDNo. 640 2009 UPPER DECK $0.40