JAY PAYTON   Rookie Card

Value & price guide for JAY PAYTON rookie cards — updated 2026.

JAY PAYTON Baseball Cards

This page lists all known JAY PAYTON rookie cards — 14 cards in our database spanning 1995–2009, covering sets from UPPER DECK, BOWMAN, STUDIO and more. Prices are sourced from recent market sales and reflect current collector values.

#1 Rookie Card

JAY PAYTON

$2.00
1995 BOWMAN 1995 BOWMAN set No. 240
#2

JAY PAYTON

$0.30
1997 BOWMAN 1997 BOWMAN set No. 151
#3

JAY PAYTON

$0.30
2001 BOWMAN 2001 BOWMAN set No. 61
#4

JAY PAYTON

$0.30
2001 UPPER DECK 2001 UPPER DECK set No. 417
#5

JAY PAYTON

$0.30
2003 UPPER DECK 2003 UPPER DECK set No. 500
#6

JAY PAYTON

$0.30
2004 UPPER DECK 2004 UPPER DECK set No. 258
#7

JAY PAYTON

$0.40
2005 STUDIO 2005 STUDIO set No. 49
#8

JAY PAYTON

$0.30
2005 UPPER DECK 2005 UPPER DECK set No. 165
#9

JAY PAYTON

$0.40
2006 FLEER 2006 FLEER set No. 36
#10

JAY PAYTON

$0.40
2006 UPPER DECK 2006 UPPER DECK set No. 330
#11

JAY PAYTON

$0.40
2007 UPPER DECK 2007 UPPER DECK set No. 184
#12

JAY PAYTON

$0.40
2007 UPPER DECK 2007 UPPER DECK set No. 568
#13

JAY PAYTON

$0.40
2008 UPPER DECK 2008 UPPER DECK set No. 423
#14

JAY PAYTON

$0.40
2009 UPPER DECK 2009 UPPER DECK set No. 39